Windows Server 2008, can’t ping, but networking is fine

pingwindows-server-2008

I'm setting up a Windows Server 2008 box, and everything is working great (database, remote login, etc.), but it doesn't respond to ping. Normally I might not care, but I'm setting up Nagios monitoring for it, too, and Nagios seems to want to know it can ping it.

My first thought was the firewall, but I even tried turning the firewall off entirely for a minute, and I still couldn't ping it.

What am I missing? Is there something I need to enable/disable to make ping work?

(Have pity … I'm normally a Unix admin, not a Windows admin. 🙂

Best Answer

Ah, I'm an idiot. I'd tried turning the firewall off but only managed to do so for one profile. The public profile (duh) was indeed blocking ICMP ECHO.

Solved...