ZFS and green drives/TLER

hard drivenetwork-attached-storageraid

I'm setting up a NAS box based around freenas and ZFS.

I've read lots of posts (like this one) about "deep recovery" and green drives when using RAID-5.

Does ZFS (vs Raid-5) mean that this problem goes away, or should I still be looking at Red or Black drives to put into my NAS?

Best Answer

WDC Green drives have the "deep recovery" problem. You'll need Red or RE drives to avoid it.

I have a ZFS RAIDZ of Green drives at home. They've lasted almost 3 years of Power On Hours without a single error. This may be just lucky, but errors don't generally happen all that often. So you have to ask, is the cost difference worth it. Take the value of up-time multiply by the likelihood of failure, now you have the amount of additional money you should spend on tech that would mitigate that potential failure mode. In most business situations, the answer is going to be a clear yes, as the cost difference is fairly small.