Programming Practices – Using GUI Designer Tools with Code Generation in Java/C++

I was actually once involved in working on a web app, which we eventually almost ended up marketing as a standard "desktop application". For some reason, Marketing got it into their heads that one of our major clients wanted the product to "appear to be a GUI application", so we created a little Windows app that just hosts the IE ActiveX control, and points to our web app (hiding the fact that it's actually a browser). So effectively, to an untrained eye it looked like the product was a standard GUI app.

Granted, this isn't exactly what you're asking (we were still pointing at a web app, and not hosting the whole thing locally) - but it's close enough. It would have been trivial - minus some of the remote web services it used - to set this up to just have the whole thing sitting on the local machine.

Here was the biggest problem though: look and feel. Especially feel.

People expect certain behaviours from rich GUI apps (drag and drop, native-feeling windows and dialogs, etc). It is extremely hard to get a genuinely native look and feel from a web frontend. There is simply a different user flow in what is expected when you open up a web app in a browser (eg. Gmail), as opposed to when you use a rich GUI application (eg. Outlook). In my experience, trying to equate the two is asking for trouble. If you put out a "GUI app" which acts like a web app, you're likely to be flooded with usability and LAF complaints.

TL;DR - Web apps and GUI apps have different looks and feels, and a different user culture to some extent. While it's technically possible to do something like this, from my experience, I wouldn't go there (again). At best you're likely to end up with a horrendous mix of client-side scripting that will be more difficult to learn, use and maintain than doing the whole thing as a normal GUI app in the first place. And people WILL complain about things "not quite feeling right" for a native GUI app. It's tempting to think that they won't - but they will.

I have never actually found a visual designer that makes it easy to create robust designs (if anyone has any they like, feel free to correct me). They are nice for dumping stuff on a fixed-size window to mock things up, but when it comes to making something that resizes nicely, plays well with DPI and themes, and all the other stuff that separates a professional UI from a merely "good-enough" one, they honestly become more work than just coding it up yourself (assuming a decent UI framework to play with).

Visual designers are excellent for rapidly prototyping software, trialling designs, and playing around to see how stuff looks, but I wouldn't use one for the final build.