edge detectionhough-transformopencv
I'm new to image processing and I'm working on detecting lines in a document image. I read the theory of Hough line transform but I can't see why I must use Canny before calling that function in opencv like being said in many tutorials. What's the point of finding edges in this case? The fact is that if I don't use Canny or threshold before HoughLines() the results will be very messy. I hope someone will explain for me the reason why.
2 of the tutorials I've read:
I'm Martin's friend who was working on this earlier this year. This was my first ever coding project, and kinda ended in a bit of a rush, so the code needs some errr...decoding... I'll give a few tips from what I've seen you doing already, and then sort my code on my day off tomorrow.
First tip, OpenCV and python are awesome, move to them as soon as possible. :D
Instead of removing small objects and or noise, lower the canny restraints, so it accepts more edges, and then find the largest closed contour (in OpenCV use findcontour() with some simple parameters, I think I used CV_RETR_LIST). might still struggle when it's on a white piece of paper, but was definitely providing best results.
For the Houghline2() Transform, try with the CV_HOUGH_STANDARD as opposed to the CV_HOUGH_PROBABILISTIC, it'll give rho and theta values, defining the line in polar coordinates, and then you can group the lines within a certain tolerance to those.
My grouping worked as a look up table, for each line outputted from the hough transform it would give a rho and theta pair. If these values were within, say 5% of a pair of values in the table, they were discarded, if they were outside that 5%, a new entry was added to the table.
You can then do analysis of parallel lines or distance between lines much more easily.
Hope this helps.
An alternative approach would be to extract features (keypoints) using the scale-invariant feature transform (SIFT) or Speeded Up Robust Features (SURF).
You can find a nice OpenCV code example in Java, C++, and Python on this page: Features2D + Homography to find a known object
Both algorithms are invariant to scaling and rotation. Since they work with features, you can also handle occlusion (as long as enough keypoints are visible).
Image source: tutorial example
The processing takes a few hundred ms for SIFT, SURF is bit faster, but it not suitable for real-time applications. ORB uses FAST which is weaker regarding rotation invariance.
Best Answer
First of all, to detect lines you need to work on a
booleanmatrix image (or binary), I mean: the color is black or white, there's no grayscale.HoughLines()'s requirement to work properly is to have this kind of image as input. That's the reason you have to useCannyorTreshold, to convert the colored image matrix into a boolean one.Hough transformation
A line in one picture is actually an edge. Hough transform scans the whole image and using a transformation that converts all white pixel cartesian coordinates in polar coordinates; the black pixels are left out. So you won't be able to get a line if you first don't detect edges, because
HoughLines()don't know how to behave when there's a grayscale.