Getting the value of a specific element from a different row in gnuplot

I think you should include a column with just the x number, say foo.jsp=1 , bar.jsp=2, etc. and suppose you put this in the first column.

So your datafile would look like:

1 foo.jsp 1234
2 bar.jsp 6653
3 foobar.jsp 9986
2 bar.jsp 2221
1 foo.jsp 5643

Then use:

plot "datafile.dat" using 1:3:xtic(2) with points

You're so close!

Change

plot "print_1012720" using 1:2 title "Flow 1", \
plot "print_1058167" using 1:2 title "Flow 2", \
plot "print_193548"  using 1:2 title "Flow 3", \ 
plot "print_401125"  using 1:2 title "Flow 4", \
plot "print_401275"  using 1:2 title "Flow 5", \
plot "print_401276"  using 1:2 title "Flow 6"

to

plot "print_1012720" using 1:2 title "Flow 1", \
     "print_1058167" using 1:2 title "Flow 2", \
     "print_193548"  using 1:2 title "Flow 3", \ 
     "print_401125"  using 1:2 title "Flow 4", \
     "print_401275"  using 1:2 title "Flow 5", \
     "print_401276"  using 1:2 title "Flow 6"

The error arises because gnuplot is trying to interpret the word "plot" as the filename to plot, but you haven't assigned any strings to a variable named "plot" (which is good – that would be super confusing).