How to convert Linux cron jobs to “the Amazon way”

amazon ec2amazon-swfcronlampscheduled-tasks

For better or worse, we have migrated our whole LAMP web application from dedicated machines to the cloud (Amazon EC2 machines). It's going great so far but the way we do crons is sub-optimal. I have a Amazon-specific question about how to best manage cron jobs in the cloud using "the Amazon way".

The problem: We have multiple webservers, and need to run crons for batch jobs such as creating RSS feeds, triggering emails, many different things actually. BUT the cron jobs need to only run on one machine because they often write to the database so would duplicate the results if run on multiple machines.

So far, we designated one of the webservers as the "master-webserver" and it has a few "special" tasks that the other webservers don't have. The trade-off for cloud computing is reliability – we don't want a "master-webserver" because it's a single point of failure. We want them to all be identical and to be able to upscale and downscale without remembering not to take the master-webserver out of the cluster.

How can we redesign our application to convert Linux cron jobs into transitory work items that don't have a single point of failure?

My ideas so far:

  • Have a machine dedicated to only running crons. This would be a little more manageable but would still be a single-point-of-failure, and would waste some money having an extra instance.
  • Some jobs could conceivably be moved from Linux crons to MySQL Events however I'm not a big fan of this idea as I don't want to put application logic into the database layer.
  • Perhaps we can run all crons on all machines but change our cron scripts so they all start with a bit of logic that implements a locking mechanism so only one server actually takes action and the others just skip. I'm not a fan of this idea as it sounds potentially buggy and I would prefer to use a Amazon best-practice rather than rolling our own.
  • I'm imagining a situation where jobs are scheduled somewhere, added to a queue and then the webservers could each be a worker, that can say "hey, I'll take this one". Amazon Simple Workflow Service sounds exactly this kind of thing but I don't currently know much about it so any specifics would be helpful. It seems kind of heavy-weight for something as simple as a cron? Is it the right service or is there a more suitable Amazon service?

Update: Since asking the question I have watched the Amazon Simple Workflow Service webinar on YouTube and noticed at 34:40 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBUQiek8Jqk#t=34m40s) I caught a glimpse of a slide mentioning cron jobs as a sample application. In their documentation page, "AWS Flow Framework samples for Amazon SWF", Amazon say they have sample code for crons:


> Cron jobs In this sample, a long running workflow periodically
executes an activity. The ability to continue executions as new
executions so that an execution can run for very extended periods of
time is demonstrated.

I downloaded the AWS SDK for Java (http://aws.amazon.com/sdkforjava/) and sure enough buried within a ridiculous layers of folders there is some java code (aws-java-sdk-1.3.6/samples/AwsFlowFramework/src/com/amazonaws/services/simpleworkflow/flow/examples/periodicworkflow).

The problem is, if I'm honest, this doesn't really help as it's not something I can easily digest with my skillset. The same sample is missing from the PHP SDK and there doesn't seem to be a tutorial that walks though the process. So basically, I'm still hunting for advice or tips.

Best Answer

I signed up for Amazon Gold support to ask them this question, this was their response:

Tom

I did a quick poll of some of my colleagues and came up empty on the cron, but after sleeping on it I realised the important step may be limited to locking. So I looked for "distributed cron job locking" and found a reference to Zookeeper, an Apache project.

http://zookeeper.apache.org/doc/r3.2.2/recipes.html

http://highscalability.com/blog/2010/3/22/7-secrets-to-successfully-scaling-with-scalr-on-amazon-by-se.html

Also I have seen reference to using memcached or a similar caching mechanism as a way to create locks with a TTL. In this way you set a flag, with a TTL of 300 seconds and no other cron worker will execute the job. The lock will automatically be released after the TTL has expired. This is conceptually very similar to the SQS option we discussed yesterday.

Also see; Google's chubby http://static.googleusercontent.com/external_content/untrusted_dlcp/research.google.com/en//archive/chubby-osdi06.pdf

Let me know if this helps, and feel free to ask questions, we are very aware that our services can be complex and daunting to both beginners and seasoned developers alike. We are always happy to offer architecture and best practice advice.

Best regards,

Ronan G. Amazon Web Services

Related Topic