R – How to: quad core and dual quad core virtualization

cpuhyper-vsmpvmware-server

On top of a dual quad core physical host, I would like to run a single VM with 8 virtual CPU (if possible) or at least 4 virtual CPU – for the purpose of scientific computing.

I have investigated what the market has to offer at this date and it seems that

VMWare Server 2.0 is limited to 2 virtual CPU.
Microsoft Virtual Server 2005 RC2 is limited to single CPU.
Microsoft Hyper-V 2008 is limited to 4 virtual CPU (with restriction on the guest OS).

Is there any solution to get 8 virtual CPUs?

Best Answer

Xen, KVM, VirtualBox, all can emulate more CPUs than you have, up to 32 CPUs per VM, at least.

Windows

Some of the above values are easily available from the appropriate Win32 API, I just list them here for completeness. Others, however, need to be obtained from the Performance Data Helper library (PDH), which is a bit "unintuitive" and takes a lot of painful trial and error to get to work. (At least it took me quite a while, perhaps I've been only a bit stupid...)

Note: for clarity all error checking has been omitted from the following code. Do check the return codes...!

Total Virtual Memory:
```
#include "windows.h"

MEMORYSTATUSEX memInfo;
memInfo.dwLength = sizeof(MEMORYSTATUSEX);
GlobalMemoryStatusEx(&memInfo);
DWORDLONG totalVirtualMem = memInfo.ullTotalPageFile;
```
Note: The name "TotalPageFile" is a bit misleading here. In reality this parameter gives the "Virtual Memory Size", which is size of swap file plus installed RAM.

Virtual Memory currently used:

Same code as in "Total Virtual Memory" and then

 DWORDLONG virtualMemUsed = memInfo.ullTotalPageFile - memInfo.ullAvailPageFile;

Virtual Memory currently used by current process:

#include "windows.h"
#include "psapi.h"

PROCESS_MEMORY_COUNTERS_EX pmc;
GetProcessMemoryInfo(GetCurrentProcess(), (PROCESS_MEMORY_COUNTERS*)&pmc, sizeof(pmc));
SIZE_T virtualMemUsedByMe = pmc.PrivateUsage;

Total Physical Memory (RAM):

Same code as in "Total Virtual Memory" and then
```
DWORDLONG totalPhysMem = memInfo.ullTotalPhys;
```
Physical Memory currently used:

Same code as in "Total Virtual Memory" and then
```
DWORDLONG physMemUsed = memInfo.ullTotalPhys - memInfo.ullAvailPhys;
```
Physical Memory currently used by current process:

Same code as in "Virtual Memory currently used by current process" and then
```
SIZE_T physMemUsedByMe = pmc.WorkingSetSize;
```

CPU currently used:

#include "TCHAR.h"
#include "pdh.h"

static PDH_HQUERY cpuQuery;
static PDH_HCOUNTER cpuTotal;

void init(){
    PdhOpenQuery(NULL, NULL, &cpuQuery);
    // You can also use L"\\Processor(*)\\% Processor Time" and get individual CPU values with PdhGetFormattedCounterArray()
    PdhAddEnglishCounter(cpuQuery, L"\\Processor(_Total)\\% Processor Time", NULL, &cpuTotal);
    PdhCollectQueryData(cpuQuery);
}

double getCurrentValue(){
    PDH_FMT_COUNTERVALUE counterVal;

    PdhCollectQueryData(cpuQuery);
    PdhGetFormattedCounterValue(cpuTotal, PDH_FMT_DOUBLE, NULL, &counterVal);
    return counterVal.doubleValue;
}

CPU currently used by current process:

#include "windows.h"

static ULARGE_INTEGER lastCPU, lastSysCPU, lastUserCPU;
static int numProcessors;
static HANDLE self;

void init(){
    SYSTEM_INFO sysInfo;
    FILETIME ftime, fsys, fuser;

    GetSystemInfo(&sysInfo);
    numProcessors = sysInfo.dwNumberOfProcessors;

    GetSystemTimeAsFileTime(&ftime);
    memcpy(&lastCPU, &ftime, sizeof(FILETIME));

    self = GetCurrentProcess();
    GetProcessTimes(self, &ftime, &ftime, &fsys, &fuser);
    memcpy(&lastSysCPU, &fsys, sizeof(FILETIME));
    memcpy(&lastUserCPU, &fuser, sizeof(FILETIME));
}

double getCurrentValue(){
    FILETIME ftime, fsys, fuser;
    ULARGE_INTEGER now, sys, user;
    double percent;

    GetSystemTimeAsFileTime(&ftime);
    memcpy(&now, &ftime, sizeof(FILETIME));

    GetProcessTimes(self, &ftime, &ftime, &fsys, &fuser);
    memcpy(&sys, &fsys, sizeof(FILETIME));
    memcpy(&user, &fuser, sizeof(FILETIME));
    percent = (sys.QuadPart - lastSysCPU.QuadPart) +
        (user.QuadPart - lastUserCPU.QuadPart);
    percent /= (now.QuadPart - lastCPU.QuadPart);
    percent /= numProcessors;
    lastCPU = now;
    lastUserCPU = user;
    lastSysCPU = sys;

    return percent * 100;
}

Linux

On Linux the choice that seemed obvious at first was to use the POSIX APIs like getrusage() etc. I spent some time trying to get this to work, but never got meaningful values. When I finally checked the kernel sources themselves, I found out that apparently these APIs are not yet completely implemented as of Linux kernel 2.6!?

In the end I got all values via a combination of reading the pseudo-filesystem /proc and kernel calls.

Total Virtual Memory:

#include "sys/types.h"
#include "sys/sysinfo.h"

struct sysinfo memInfo;

sysinfo (&memInfo);
long long totalVirtualMem = memInfo.totalram;
//Add other values in next statement to avoid int overflow on right hand side...
totalVirtualMem += memInfo.totalswap;
totalVirtualMem *= memInfo.mem_unit;

Virtual Memory currently used:

Same code as in "Total Virtual Memory" and then

long long virtualMemUsed = memInfo.totalram - memInfo.freeram;
//Add other values in next statement to avoid int overflow on right hand side...
virtualMemUsed += memInfo.totalswap - memInfo.freeswap;
virtualMemUsed *= memInfo.mem_unit;

Virtual Memory currently used by current process:

#include "stdlib.h"
#include "stdio.h"
#include "string.h"

int parseLine(char* line){
    // This assumes that a digit will be found and the line ends in " Kb".
    int i = strlen(line);
    const char* p = line;
    while (*p <'0' || *p > '9') p++;
    line[i-3] = '\0';
    i = atoi(p);
    return i;
}

int getValue(){ //Note: this value is in KB!
    FILE* file = fopen("/proc/self/status", "r");
    int result = -1;
    char line[128];

    while (fgets(line, 128, file) != NULL){
        if (strncmp(line, "VmSize:", 7) == 0){
            result = parseLine(line);
            break;
        }
    }
    fclose(file);
    return result;
}

Total Physical Memory (RAM):

Same code as in "Total Virtual Memory" and then

long long totalPhysMem = memInfo.totalram;
//Multiply in next statement to avoid int overflow on right hand side...
totalPhysMem *= memInfo.mem_unit;

Physical Memory currently used:

Same code as in "Total Virtual Memory" and then

long long physMemUsed = memInfo.totalram - memInfo.freeram;
//Multiply in next statement to avoid int overflow on right hand side...
physMemUsed *= memInfo.mem_unit;

Physical Memory currently used by current process:

Change getValue() in "Virtual Memory currently used by current process" as follows:

int getValue(){ //Note: this value is in KB!
    FILE* file = fopen("/proc/self/status", "r");
    int result = -1;
    char line[128];

    while (fgets(line, 128, file) != NULL){
        if (strncmp(line, "VmRSS:", 6) == 0){
            result = parseLine(line);
            break;
        }
    }
    fclose(file);
    return result;
}

CPU currently used:

#include "stdlib.h"
#include "stdio.h"
#include "string.h"

static unsigned long long lastTotalUser, lastTotalUserLow, lastTotalSys, lastTotalIdle;

void init(){
    FILE* file = fopen("/proc/stat", "r");
    fscanf(file, "cpu %llu %llu %llu %llu", &lastTotalUser, &lastTotalUserLow,
        &lastTotalSys, &lastTotalIdle);
    fclose(file);
}

double getCurrentValue(){
    double percent;
    FILE* file;
    unsigned long long totalUser, totalUserLow, totalSys, totalIdle, total;

    file = fopen("/proc/stat", "r");
    fscanf(file, "cpu %llu %llu %llu %llu", &totalUser, &totalUserLow,
        &totalSys, &totalIdle);
    fclose(file);

    if (totalUser < lastTotalUser || totalUserLow < lastTotalUserLow ||
        totalSys < lastTotalSys || totalIdle < lastTotalIdle){
        //Overflow detection. Just skip this value.
        percent = -1.0;
    }
    else{
        total = (totalUser - lastTotalUser) + (totalUserLow - lastTotalUserLow) +
            (totalSys - lastTotalSys);
        percent = total;
        total += (totalIdle - lastTotalIdle);
        percent /= total;
        percent *= 100;
    }

    lastTotalUser = totalUser;
    lastTotalUserLow = totalUserLow;
    lastTotalSys = totalSys;
    lastTotalIdle = totalIdle;

    return percent;
}

CPU currently used by current process:

#include "stdlib.h"
#include "stdio.h"
#include "string.h"
#include "sys/times.h"
#include "sys/vtimes.h"

static clock_t lastCPU, lastSysCPU, lastUserCPU;
static int numProcessors;

void init(){
    FILE* file;
    struct tms timeSample;
    char line[128];

    lastCPU = times(&timeSample);
    lastSysCPU = timeSample.tms_stime;
    lastUserCPU = timeSample.tms_utime;

    file = fopen("/proc/cpuinfo", "r");
    numProcessors = 0;
    while(fgets(line, 128, file) != NULL){
        if (strncmp(line, "processor", 9) == 0) numProcessors++;
    }
    fclose(file);
}

double getCurrentValue(){
    struct tms timeSample;
    clock_t now;
    double percent;

    now = times(&timeSample);
    if (now <= lastCPU || timeSample.tms_stime < lastSysCPU ||
        timeSample.tms_utime < lastUserCPU){
        //Overflow detection. Just skip this value.
        percent = -1.0;
    }
    else{
        percent = (timeSample.tms_stime - lastSysCPU) +
            (timeSample.tms_utime - lastUserCPU);
        percent /= (now - lastCPU);
        percent /= numProcessors;
        percent *= 100;
    }
    lastCPU = now;
    lastSysCPU = timeSample.tms_stime;
    lastUserCPU = timeSample.tms_utime;

    return percent;
}

TODO: Other Platforms

I would assume, that some of the Linux code also works for the Unixes, except for the parts that read the /proc pseudo-filesystem. Perhaps on Unix these parts can be replaced by getrusage() and similar functions?

R – I need more VMs, should I expand the current server, or just get another server to host them

We have a similar configuration as to what you'd be looking to upgrade to.

Dual Quad Core Xeon
8Gb RAM (server can handle up to 32Gb)
VMWare ESXi

We're running about 25 VMs at the moment and will eventually end up with the full 32Gb of RAM as our demands increase. Most are just testing machines for our support team to replicate customer environments so are just idling 24/7, we've got 8Gb physical ram with 16Gb allocated to VMs - usually not a problem unless we're actively using multiple Vista or Server 2008 VMs.

The first upgrade we went thru was to get a hardware RAID card (to support ESXi) which boosted performance like you wouldn't believe (software raid + vista = ugh!), next steps will be upgrading ram to 12Gb, then 16Gb as we add more and more VMs. Once memory price falls enough we'll start replacing pairs of 2Gb sticks with pairs of 4Gb ones.

Even under heavy load, the bottleneck on our machine is memory. So I'd suggest upgrading your current machine, there's plenty of life left in it yet.

Best Answer

Related Solutions

C++ – How to determine CPU and memory consumption from inside a process

Windows

Linux

TODO: Other Platforms

R – I need more VMs, should I expand the current server, or just get another server to host them

Related Topic