Is there a clean way to redirect all attempts to going to an HTTP:// version of a site to its HTTPS:// equivalent?
Xml – IIS7: HTTP->HTTPS Cleanly
httpsiis-7xml
Related Solutions
There's a very simple answer to this: Profile the performance of your web server to see what the performance penalty is for your particular situation. There are several tools out there to compare the performance of an HTTP vs HTTPS server (JMeter and Visual Studio come to mind) and they are quite easy to use.
No one can give you a meaningful answer without some information about the nature of your web site, hardware, software, and network configuration.
As others have said, there will be some level of overhead due to encryption, but it is highly dependent on:
- Hardware
- Server software
- Ratio of dynamic vs static content
- Client distance to server
- Typical session length
- Etc (my personal favorite)
- Caching behavior of clients
In my experience, servers that are heavy on dynamic content tend to be impacted less by HTTPS because the time spent encrypting (SSL-overhead) is insignificant compared to content generation time.
Servers that are heavy on serving a fairly small set of static pages that can easily be cached in memory suffer from a much higher overhead (in one case, throughput was havled on an "intranet").
Edit: One point that has been brought up by several others is that SSL handshaking is the major cost of HTTPS. That is correct, which is why "typical session length" and "caching behavior of clients" are important.
Many, very short sessions means that handshaking time will overwhelm any other performance factors. Longer sessions will mean the handshaking cost will be incurred at the start of the session, but subsequent requests will have relatively low overhead.
Client caching can be done at several steps, anywhere from a large-scale proxy server down to the individual browser cache. Generally HTTPS content will not be cached in a shared cache (though a few proxy servers can exploit a man-in-the-middle type behavior to achieve this). Many browsers cache HTTPS content for the current session and often times across sessions. The impact the not-caching or less caching means clients will retrieve the same content more frequently. This results in more requests and bandwidth to service the same number of users.
Yes, the SSL connection is between the TCP layer and the HTTP layer. The client and server first establish a secure encrypted TCP connection (via the SSL/TLS protocol) and then the client will send the HTTP request (GET, POST, DELETE...) over that encrypted TCP connection.
Best Answer
I think the cleanest way is as described here on IIS-aid.com. It's web.config only and so if you change server you don't have to remember all the steps you went through with the 403.4 custom error page or other special permissions, it just works.