facebook-groupsphoto-sharingprivacy
Me and my friends have a secret Facebook group we use to share most of our photos.
We now post all of our photos in the secret group because it's just convenient.
But is there a way I can share a photo from the secret group to my wall, to share it with my other Facebook friends, without having to download and re upload the photo? Because doing so removes the likes and the comment thread.
Are you referring to your News Feed (Top News), News Feed (Most Recent), or the Recent Activity on your profile?
I think that News Feed (Top News) only displays what Facebook considers to be most interesting to you, so I wouldn't expect your own likes/comments there. The News Feed setting that you mentioned applies to the Most Recent setting.
News Feed (Most Recent) does not display individual stories for comments and likes on posts; you would only see them under the corresponding post, if it is expanded. Are you saying that you expanded the likes/comments and you can see comments from other people but your comment is not there? Sometimes it takes some time for it to show up although it shouldn't take days (unless it was deleted).
If you are referring to the Recent Activity on your profile, there is an additional setting for that that you didn't mention. On your profile's Wall (not your News Feed), scroll to the bottom and click Edit Options. If you have hidden any kinds of stories from your Recent Activity these will be listed and you can unhide any of them by clicking the X and then Save.
As for the Photos tab, that used to be a known issue although the link to Facebook Help in that answer does not seem to work now. I don't know if that means that it should be fixed.
You can try tagging yourself in the pictures, so you both your friends and hers can see the pictures. The best way to tackle it is by just adding the pictures on her Facebook (with privacy setting Friends of friends) and sharing it once on your wall.
Hope this helps you.
Best Answer
I figured out that the most efficient way to solve this problem is to use the native photo album feature from facebook. When creating an album you can select who can all see the pictures, pictures that are then tagged are automatically shared with friends, this is a much more efficient approach then using groups.