Gmail filters based on label and starred

Not automatically you can't.

You can set up a very generic filter that should capture most of the legit mailing lists that you're subscribed to.

Create a filter with the following:

• Has the words: unsubscribe
• Apply the label: lists

This will deal with most of the mailing lists since they should all include instructions, if not a link itself, to unsubscribe.

This should also cover those instances where the mailer addresses the To: field of the email directly to you and which might be a little tricky when filtering for to:me.

I don't think Google supports this feature, but I found a workaround from 2008 that might still work:

1. Create the group in My Contacts
2. Compose an email to said group
3. Copy the "To:" field
4. Paste into the "Convert" textbox here
5. Copy the the "Convert" output into a new filter

Try it and let us know if it does what you're looking for.