How does the variation on the kind of the load of a transformer affects efficiency and regulation? If I use a capacitive load, will the efficiency be greater or lower than if I use a common inductive load?
Electrical – Transformer with different kinds of loads
transformer
Related Solutions
Increasing current causes increasing copper losses due to resistance.
Resistive loss is determined by current^2 x resistance. BUT,
Power is determined by voltage x current.
So if you increase power from 100% to 110% the copper losses rise by
(110%/100%)^2 = 1.1^2 = 1.21 ie losses increase by 21% for 10% more power.
Copper resistive energy loss is turned directly into heat.
A transformer will be designed to have a safe temperature rise at rated power in the worst case environmental conditions that it is guaranteed to work in.
Add 20% more heat and things may get "interesting"/ Short term failures may occur.
But, if not, inter-winding insulation will "cook" and perish, wire insulation may fail.
Iron losses due to hysteresis will also increase. Brain offers that this will be linear with current but brain may be wrong.
Increased temperature may affect magnetic property of the core steel. IF core permeability drops even slightly then flux will drop and inductance will drop and current per applied volt will rise and copper loss will increase and temperature will increase and ... .
Thermal runaway is not usually seen in domestic size transformers. Fortunately.
This page from Elliot Sound products notes:
Keeping a transformer as cool as possible is always a good idea. At elevated temperatures the life of the insulation is reduced, and the resistance also increases further because copper has a positive temperature coefficient of resistance.
As the transformer gets hot, its resistance increases, increasing losses. This (naturally) leads to greater losses that cause the transformer to get hotter. There is a real risk of drastically reduced operational life (or even localised "hot-spot" thermal runaway) if any transformer is pushed too far - especially if there is inadequate (or blocked) cooling.
It is generally accepted that any transformer will have one part of the winding that (for a variety of reasons) is hotter than the rest.
It's also a rule of thumb that the life expectancy of insulation (amongst other things) is halved for every 10°C (some claim as low as 7°C).
When these two factors are combined, it is apparent that any transformer operated at a consistently high temperature will eventually fail due to insulation breakdown. The likelihood of this happening with a home system is small, but it's a constant risk for power distribution transformers.Despite all this, mains frequency iron cored transformers typically outlast the product they are powering, and even recycled transformers can easily outlast their second or third incarnation. Once a transformer is over 50 years old I suggest that the chassis be earthed, as the insulation can no longer be trusted at that age.
Added 8 years on :-).
Not directly asked about but related and worth noting: Transformer manufacturers seek to minimise cost (of course) and using as little lamination material as reasonably possible is a target. The core is usually designed to operate at the knee of its flux BH curve where increasing amp-turns start to give increasingly less flux per amp-turn as the core is driven further into saturation.
Transformers designed for 60 Hz operation can use usefully less core material due to the increased impedance at higher frequency (Z = 2.Pi.f.l).
However, operating a transformer designed for 60 Hz in a 50 Hz environment can lead to very substantial excess heating.
While this is not normally encountered it does happen. Two examples:
People bringing equipment from eg the US to NZ not only need to adjust transformer tappings (if availaable) to accommodate the 100 VAC to 230 VAC change but also need to take account for the change from 60 Hz (USA) to 50 Hz (NZ)
I once had a custom 500 watt mains power transformer would in New Zealand for use in a test box in a Taiwanese factory. Their mains is 110VAC and hours is nominally 230 VAC. I specified two primary windings that could be connected in series or parallel to allow operation in either country. In the specification I did not mention Taiwan but I did tell the manufacturer that it was for use in Taiwan, ultimately. He took it on himself, without asking or telling me, to design it for 60 Hz operation. NZ uses 50 Hz. While a 50 Hz design would have worked well in Taiwan, the opposite was not as true as I would have liked. In NZ on test it ran VERY hot - it took me a wee while to realise why.
In short: no.
In "long": it doesn't mean that and, while it may be possible to be so, don't forget that the current capability is directly related to the cross-wire section (area), which means making it generate more than it was planned to will most surely heat it up and, possibly, permanently deteriorate the transformer.
However, seeing that you have 3x8V, it may be possible to connect the windings in parallel, thus granting you the ability to deliver 3 x current, but for that you need to separate the windings so that they are completely separate, then connect them properly in parallel (hot end to hot end), i.e. not in anti-parallel.
Even so, I would discourage this because the windings themselves may not be equal, that is, the 0-6 one may have the average turn length less than the 18-24 one would, meaning that the internal secondary impedances will differ, resulting in other possible cases of deterioration. If, by any chance, you get here, equality may be brought by inserting series resistances on each winding (two at least), at the cost of more losses.
Related Topic
- Given thermal capability of a transformer, how to best estimate the voltage regulation
- Electronic – If a step-up transformer increases voltage, then how current can be decreased ? is really the current in output is smaller
- Electrical – Regulation of transformer with inductive load
- Electronic – Apparent power calculation of different loads for transformer sizing
- Electronic – In a flyback transformer with multiple windings, how are voltages controlled for different current loads
- Electronic – How does efficiency of transformer change with respect to primary voltage
Best Answer
If you use a capacitive or inductive load, then the overall efficiency of the system will be zero, as either of those loads consume zero power, while the transformer will have losses.
The losses of a transformer are essentially core loss, which is dependent on the applied voltage, and copper loss, which is dependent on the current. At first sight it may seem therefore that for the same load current and load voltage, the transformer losses will be the same, regardless of whether the load is inductive, capacitive or resistive.
There is a subtlety that the magnetising current is in quadrature phase to the applied voltage. This means that for load currents in the order of the magnetising current Imag (that is, an order of magnitude or two less than the full power rating of the transformer), the primary current will be 2 times Imag for an inductive load, 1.4 times for a resistive load, and zero for a capacitive load, with the corresponding effect on transformer copper losses.
However, for load currents much greater than Imag, the load current will dominate the copper loss regardless of its phase with respect to Imag.