Electronic – Derate heatsink when used passively

heatsink

I want to reuse my old computer processor heatsinks for LED heatsinking. I think I can calculate their K/W value approximately by dividing the temperature difference vs TDP at their maximum load.

I ignore the CPU packaging thermal resistance and take it as an additional safety margin.
This way I get about 60/100 = 0.6K/W for a beefy heatsink.

The problem is, that I want to get rid of the active component and derate the heatsink accordingly. Are there any approximations I can use for derating?

I know I'll have to add a healthy safety margin, but I still need a general figure as to decide what wattage can they sink.

Best Answer

It is a challenging problem to de-rate a heat sink. The problem is that if a heat sink is designed for forced air cooling (using a fan), the spacing between fins is optimized for forced air, and usually is fairly dense, 1.5-2mm apart. For cooling with free convection however, the fin spacing must be at least 1/4" (6mm) or more, for the ambient air to flow between fins with any reasonable velocity, and for thermal boundary layers not to overlap along the fins. Needless to say, you should maintain vertical orientation of cooling surface and vertical orientation of fins to have any positive effect.

In other words, forced-air heat sinks are usually unsuitable for free convection cooling. The best safe estimate would be to consider the entire heat sink as a brick.

Related Topic