Electronic – Does the Shockley diode equation apply to Schottky diodes and non-silicon diodes

diodesmodeling

As I'm sure most people here know, the Shockley diode equation is

$$ I_d=I_s[e^{\frac{V_d}{nV_t}}-1] $$

Notice that none of the quantities here other than \$I_s\$ and \$n\$ are dependent on the diode itself. \$n\$ varies widely even sticking to just silicon diodes, so clearly the different voltage drop of other diode types can't be adequately explained by that.

Is the variance in \$I_s\$ alone adequate to describe Schottky junctions or diodes of other semiconductors (like GaAs or SiC or the wide range of LED semiconductors), to the same accuracy that the equation describes silicon diodes? Or is there some assumption built into the equation that makes it only valid for silicon diodes? Can \$n\$ be far outside the [1,2] range it's commonly cited as being restricted to, in non-silicon diodes? Are there dropped terms that are very small for silicon diodes that are non-negligible for other types?

Best Answer

The Shockley equation with minor modifications is what is used in SPICE simulations for forward current in silicon, Schottky, and LED diodes.

enter image description here

The parameter list is given as (from here):

enter image description here

The main difference between the different types (other than the number such as Is which is quite different for an LED) is the temperature dependence of the saturation current for Schottky diodes. It includes a resistance term.

The reverse bias treatment is different from the Shockley equation and includes the GMIN for voltages < -5nV and the breakdown region exponential (the latter of which isn't covered by the Shockley equation). The GMIN business is to aid convergence of the diffeq solver rather than to improve accuracy.

Note: Vj (junction potential) and M (grading coefficient) are used to model the capacitance of the diode- M is important in reverse bias and Vj for forward bias.

As an example of an LED model, the LTspice model for Lumileds LXHL-BW02 (a 350mA power LED) has Is = 4.5E-20, N=2.6, Rs=0.85

In general you will not find the saturation current on a diode datasheet (you should not use the reverse leakage term), rather you would adjust IS and N to fit the forward V-I curve.

Related Topic