Electronic – How to choose the right frequency when measuring coil inductance with LCR meter

coildriverinductancelcr

I would like to drive a 12V DC hydraulic valve coil using a high side driver (VN7140AJ). The driver datasheet specifies the maximum demagnetization energy (page 24), and I would like to make sure that I can drive the coil without damaging the driver.

The datasheet for the valve does not specify its inductance and the manufacturer doesn't seem to know what I am talking about, so I decided to measure the coil inductance myself. I have a DE-5000 LCR meter, but depending on the frequency I select, the measured inductance changes:

  • 100 kHz → 4.681 mH
  • 10 kHz → 7.578 mH
  • 1 kHz → 21.79 mH
  • 120 Hz → 52.44 mH
  • 100 Hz → 55.71 mH

Knowing that I'll be driving the coil at < 1 Hz, what frequency setting should I choose on the LCR meter, to obtain a value that can be checked against the demagnetization graph in the driver datasheet?

Best Answer

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

You have a large coil with lots of turns, each turn has its resistance and inductance. Between each turn there is also a capacitance, this is because the wires are close with each other, separated with a thin layer of insulator.

The LCR meter measures the phase shift voltage VS. current. At high frequency the capacitance becomes more and more dominant, so your LCR meter "thinks" the inductance is decaying.

You can see those effects, described in this paper.

enter image description here

enter image description here

That's a very similar scenario as yours. At low frequency, the inductance is dominant up to resonance point, then the capacitance is dominant. You can see also the resistance increase due to skin effect.