Electronic – Is it mandatory to use thermals in hand soldered PCBs

pcbpcb-designsoldering

I understand thermals are used to prevent tombstoning during oven soldering by allowing all pads to heat up more evenly, but are they necessary when the PCB is going to be soldered by hand?

Consider that I have experience soldering SMDs and that I have a good soldering station(as in one that has no problem soldering heavy packages and heavy wire).

Also, the PCB will have solder mask so solder won't just run around, etc..

I ask this because I'm designing a 2 layer PCB which is quite dense in some places and disabling thermals allows me to leave more copper on the power pours in dense areas..

Below image without(left) and with thermals(right).

enter image description here

Best Answer

In my opinion, if you are hand-soldering the board and have a decent soldering iron, you don't need thermals.

I regularly hand-solder on ground planes with stitched vias (RF boards) with no problems. Because these are RF ground planes, they don't have thermal relief for the vias.

FWIW - my old Weller soldering station isn't happy soldering large ground plane areas. On the other hand, my Metcal MX-500 with a sttc-113 tip works well. I was doing a bunch of soldering of RG-58 shield braid on ground plane earlier today with absolutely no problems.