Electronic – Selectable Voltage Regulator Circuit

component-selectionvoltage-regulator

Background

I would like to make a simple battery-powered circuit with two alternatively selectable linear voltage regulators to set the output voltage.

Question

Given the circuit below should I worry about the two regulators "upsetting" each other in any way or is this going to work just fine?

Alternatively Selectable Voltage Output

Best Answer

There is nothing wrong with your schematic the voltage regulators will not upset each other in any way.

However, it would seem if you change your LM7805 to an LM317 (or very many others) you could simply use a single regulator and change the output voltage. Look at the datasheet for any adjustable regulator such as the LM317.
This may also help you.

You'll see many arrangements such as this: enter image description here

Here they used jumpers to select the voltage, but you could just as easily use a switch.

Additional notes on "Reverse Current" regulator failures:
There is considerable mythology about this issue for this type of linear regulator and many times it's put down to these being older designs. Nothing could be further from the truth, this applies to even the most modern designs.
Looking at the datasheets for the LM7805 and the LD1117V33 you can actually map the current paths from output to input if the input is shorted. You'll notice for both there are multiple paths. In the 7805 there is a low current path that starts conduction at only about 1.6 V while the LD1117 has a full reverse Vbe of about 6 V before conduction.
enter image description here

For more modern LDO devices that use P-Channel FETs the reverse voltage capability is even lower, about 800 mV due to the intrinsic diode in the FET.
For example the LP38511 clearly shows the intrinsic diode across the power FET: enter image description here

Your design has to allow for this reverse current and this is a failure vector if you have short faults or a crowbar on the input side of the regulator. Controlling the output capacitance can help to reduce the transient currents to a safe level, but this is critical when multiple regulators feed an output as in the OP's circuit. This circuit is quite safe because the input capacitor for each regulator is not in any way clamped. So while there may be an initial current flow when changing from one regulator to the other, the respective input capacitor initially holds up the input voltage and will discharge due to load current, and then can be charged by the reverse current and still be within ratings.

To be safe against reverse current failures in the regulator you can add a Schottky diode from input to output. This provides a single well defined high current path when the output is above the input. However you have to carefully consider this in your overall circuit design as the output can now only be about 250 mV above the input under any condition.