Electronic – Use expensive or inexpensive capacitor for decoupling

capacitorcomponentscostdecoupling-capacitorsurface-mount

I'm in the middle of a project to create a small development board using a 100Mhz Cortex M4 MCU and have to buy some decoupling SMT capacitors.

I've found the following options:

Cheap 10 cent from Mouser
Expensive 50 cent from Digikey

Both appear to have the same properties but the more expensive one is listed as being for "decoupling".

I did find this link about the expensive Johanson capacitor. It appears to be a special purpose built low ESR capacitor that is said to "replace" the need for multiple capacitors.

Will the cheap capacitor be fine or should I spend the extra money on the more expensive capacitors and why?

Best Answer

The picture on page 12 of the Johanson datasheet shows the difference between it and a normal multilayer ceramic capacitor (MLCC):

enter image description here

The part on the left is a normal MLCC. The part on the right is the Johanson part.

The Johanson part is a 4-terminal part, actually a capacitor network with two separate capacitors with one shared terminal. By connecting the "A" and "B" terminals together, you obtain twice the specified capacitance. Because of the feedthrough shape of the ground terminal you also probably achieve lower equivalent inductance and a higher self-resonant frequency.

That said, 90% of designs can be done using normal MLCCs for decoupling. If you need higher self-resonant frequency, I'd recommend to first try using a smaller package than 0805, and only if that isn't adequate, consider using one of these specialized high-cost parts.