Electronic – What do we need the op amp for in this current-to-voltage converter

operational-amplifier

I'm still very new to electrical engineering and at the moment trying to get my head around the concept of the ideal op amp.

In Fundamentals of Electric Circuits by Alexander and Sadiku the following diagram is given as a "current-to-voltage converter".

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

The reader is asked to prove $$v=-IR,$$ which I think I did. But what do we need the op amp for? Wouldn't the following diagram be exactly the same?

schematic

simulate this circuit

Best Answer

Your op-amp is a vital clog in the wheel in this circuit. Since the op-amp has infinite resistance, the current I entirely flows to the alternate path through the resistor R. Note that since the + end of the op-amp is at ground and because of the infinite gain of the op-amp, the - end is also held to ground. So the drop across the resistor is V = IR. So effectively, the output of the op-amp will be held at V = IR as the output is connected between the point V which is the other end of the resistor and ground. So, it is the characteristics of the op-amp which are enabling the functionality of a current to voltage converter here.