Partial load failure detection circuit

analogcurrentfailuremeasurementrs232

I'm working on the power supply of a temperature controller which sends about 5kW of power maximum (230VAC 50Hz) into 3 sets of 12 heaters (actually, 3kW + 1kW + 1kW). I'm at the stage where I need to detect if any of those heaters burns out or shorts.
I am currently considering current monitoring with a software algorithm to detect that.

  • I have 3 RS232 lines available, and 3 analog inputs (0-10V or 0-20mA) total (unless I add something else but I'd rather not to).
  • That leaves me with 1 current monitor for the whole set, or one per heater set. Hence the specs of the current sensor: >21A full scale or >13A full scale, <100mA accuracy.
  • Non-invasive technique is required (intrinsically isolated). I don't trust chips like the Allegro ACS709 to be completely short-free over the entire lifetime (15years) because it may be isolated, but still within a very small package (but maybe I should?).

Clampmeters are very appealing because they're definitely non-invasive and they generally have good accuracy. I have found only one which has a RS232 interface though, and the datasheet is quite poor.

Any suggestions?

Best Answer

When it comes to something that appears to be as critical as this I would still go with an invasive hall-sensor but use two of them per outlet. I would also consider ones with a serial bus capability like the Allegro ACS764.

There is also an intrusive hall sensor with two port RS232 connection which allows for daisy chaining several devices here. Might be worth looking at.