Electronic – What makes some commercial JFETs asymmetric

jfetphysical-design

In a MOSFET, the obvious cause of asymmetry is the fact that the source is tied to the body. But in a JFET, no such obvious answer exists, as the body, gate, and drain are all the same piece of silicon with no material differences between them (as far as I'm aware). And indeed, most JFETs seem to be symmetric.

But there are some JFETs on the market have specifications that would imply asymmetry. See for example the UJ3N120070K3S that I just used in a design; it's rated for a gate-to-source voltage of no more than -20 volts, but a drain-to-source blocking voltage of 1200 volts. But if \$V_{ds} = 1200\ \mathrm V\$, and \$V_{gs} = -20\ \mathrm V\$, that leaves \$V_{gd} = -1220\ \mathrm V\$! Even if \$V_{gs} = 0\ \mathrm V\$, \$V_{gd}\$ is still vastly higher than the rated \$V_{gs}\$.

If the FET were symmetric, that would imply that the gate-source and gate-drain ratings should be the same, but they clearly can't be here, as if they were, the drain-source rating couldn't possibly be higher than the gate-source rating, and applying rated \$V_{ds}\$ would fry the gate junction.

What about its physical construction makes this JFET, and others like it, asymmetric? Why can \$V_{gd}\$ be so much higher than \$V_{gs}\$?

Best Answer

Many JFETs are symmetric and this is sometimes indicated in the datasheet such as the

enter image description here Source: https://shop.micross.com/pdf/LSM_2N4117A_TO-71.pdf

If it is indicated then you know its symmetric otherwise you would have to assume either.

I think this is question is backwards:

What about its physical construction makes this JFET, and others like it, asymmetric? Why can Vgd be so much higher than Vgs?

If there is asymmetry you can infer this from measurements or from the datasheet because if the physical construction were symmetrical there would be no difference.

A better question would be: Can I infer that a JFET is asymmetric if there is a difference between Vgd than Vgs. I believe the answer is yes, but you could never be sure unless you actually check the physical construction or a patent. Also if there were Cgd and Cgs listed and they were different I also think you could assume asymmetry.

This J308 "N-Channel JFET" has a different Cgd and Cgs.

enter image description here Source: https://www.digchip.com/datasheets/parts/datasheet/078/J308-pdf.php